Abstract
Aquaponics combines aquaculture and hydroponics in a closed-loop system, offering a sustainable approach to food and water challenges. Despite its potential, limited comparative evidence exists on how nutrient dynamics, water quality, and fish–plant synergy vary across regions, constraining optimization and broader adoption. This qualitative meta-analysis investigates nutrient flows and plant–fish interactions in recirculating aquaponic systems (RAS) across Kenya, the United States, India, and the Netherlands, focusing on productivity and environmental performance. A systematic review of studies published between 2010 and 2024 yielded 23 empirical sources meeting strict inclusion criteria, including metrics on nutrient fluxes, water quality, productivity, and system inputs. Data were standardized across five themes: fish–plant pairings, nutrient conversion efficiency, water quality, productivity outputs, and environmental trade-offs. Findings reveal Kenya’s low-energy systems, often incorporating local innovations such as Azolla pinnata, produced competitive yields (up to 22.1 kg/m²/yr for tilapia–tomato) with moderate nitrogen-use efficiency (up to 81%). U.S. systems showed high commercial viability, using bluegill–basil and trout–Swiss chard pairings in controlled environments, but required higher energy inputs. India’s semi-automated systems favored native species but experienced higher waste output and moderate nutrient utilization. The Netherlands led in water and nutrient efficiency achieving as low as 30 L/kg yield and 150 g/kg waste through AI-managed precision systems, though energy demands were high (up to 3.7 kWh/kg yield). Overall, optimal RAS outcomes depend on localized adaptation, species compatibility, and appropriate technological integration. These insights inform efforts to improve aquaponic sustainability, scalability, and environmental performance worldwide